My niece Golf loses her toe

by Jungle Girl on July 17, 2009

{UPDATE: Golf is doing really well, her foot is healing well though she is now feeling sad at the loss of her toe. We’re hoping that she will still do really well on her exams and can try to get into medical school next year. Thanks everybody for the kind words and support.}

On Saturday Golf came off her moped and seriously damaged two toes on her left foot. The clinic on our island patched her up and sent her to Samui to the main hospital. They estimated that if she had surgery within a few hours she would keep her toes.

Golf is an incredibly bright, beautiful, hardworking young girl whose ambition is to be a nurse in the army because (though she’s got the grades) Crab and the family can’t afford medical school for her. Yesterday at the age of nineteen she had her toes amputated.

Golf, Egger, Way, and Crab in the kitchen

The first time she saw the doctor on Samui was at 5pm in the evening, in surgery. He was notified at 10am that she needed emergency surgery. She and crab sat on the ward, while the doctor on-call failed to show for seven hours and Golf’s toe died. When he did finally grace them with his presence he didn’t even check her first to assess the damage; fully unqualified to perform surgery, he met her for the first time on the operating table, where he proceeded to butcher her foot.

Then Golf was left for twenty-four hours with a blackened, gangrenous toe hanging off her foot. No doctor checked her after surgery, no dressing was changed. When I arrived at the hospital there were four nurses sitting behind glass, with four patients in the entire ward, yet Golf had dirty bandage hanging off her foot, hair stuck in her wound, and a clearly dead body part rapidly spreading gangrene and poisoning her bloodstream.

Once Shrimp and I arrived, you’d better believe things changed fast. Because we have the confidence to kick up a fuss and we are given this right by the fact that we are educated and I am a farang. What makes my blood boil is that Golf lost her toes because she is a young, poor, Thai, with the wrong skin tone and is thus afraid to speak up to authority.

Had I been there it would not have happened, had I been there the doctor would not have treated her body part as disposable, and her surgery as a non-priority. But I wasn’t there and Golf was not deemed important, wealthy, white or powerful enough to warrant basic medical care. She lost her toe because she lives in a country where a young, poor, dark-skinned girl has no right to anything and certainly not to ask when the doctor will arrive.

I will not rant here too much. It suffices to say that I am meditating on responsibility, that I have been resistant to for a long while, that I need to step up and accept; because I do have responsibility to those whom I take care of who are not able to stand up for themselves, and who lose their toes if they don’t have someone like me to speak up for them.

It suffices to say that the doctor, the hospital administrator, the director, and the ward nurse are hopefully all meditating on their negligence, their wrong decision-making, poor management and blatant disregard for humanity. As well as the lawsuit that is coming their way.

Golf is doing well, in a private international hospital that we can’t really afford, but which I blagged her into and into amputation surgery. We will deal with the rest as it comes, she is safe, though minus a body part. As is typical of her resilience, not a tear was shed, not a drama, not a histrionic in sight, her main concern was that I might be tired running the kitchen, and that Clear Sky is happy.

The private hospital have done everything they can to help us and to smooth things over. The director has personally asked us not to sue the negligent hospital as we will be taking resources away from those who need them and doctors are scarce. I hear and respect this point, I don’t believe in litigious societies, but I do feel that this doctor was not only negligent in the extreme, but that he was negligent based on a class judgement, a reality that is common in Thailand and which he admitted to me face-to-face.

This is why while I don’t believe in the lawsuit culture we’ve come to expect in the West I do believe in accountability, and I will be thinking very hard about the best way to achieve accountability on a nineteen year old girl’s behalf, in a classist, racist, elitist, corrupt society such as this.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

Related posts:

  1. Golf is off to university…..

{ 1 trackback }

Golf is off to university…..
May 12, 2010 at 11:58 pm

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

Jennifer Case July 17, 2009 at 12:27 pm

What a horrible, sad story. She and the whole family are very lucky to have you to speak up for them.

coconutsoup July 17, 2009 at 1:53 pm

Nat, I loved your blog. We had a similar experience when our second child was born on Samui. Seemed Korean soaps were more important than uniting a mother with her her new born.

Laura July 18, 2009 at 4:34 am

What a horrific story. I'm completely speechless. Shocking beyond belief.

Jody July 20, 2009 at 11:18 am

What a tragic tale. Happily she has you to stand for her, but so many do not. While litigation may not be the direction to follow I agree that something must be done.

Thankfully a private institution was available and you could get her in. I suppose I could go on a political rant here, but I will refrain and just be thankful that you, at least, had a choice.

john July 23, 2009 at 12:38 pm

as shocking as it is i am sure she will make a very good recovery
sorry to say this is typical thai hospital care well non private ofcourse
best wishes to her and family its pointless to ask her to put some decent shoes on till the wound heals i suppose

Jungle Girl July 23, 2009 at 9:05 pm

thanks everybody for commenting – Golf is healing well with the aid of a cocktail of thai medicines (they do love a bag of pharmaceuticals don't they?). And yes John, she should have been wearing shoes on the bike, and no it won't change the fact that she'll continue not to wear shoes on the bike!
Coconut soup, I would love to hear the rest of your story about your baby's birth on Samui.
Generally I'm feeling shocked at the responses to this story, every single person I have talked to without exception has a family member maimed, crippled, dead or handicapped not by accidents per se (of which there are many but by medical malpractice, its scary..who is regualating the Thai medical industry?

fieryfairy July 26, 2009 at 12:10 pm

how horrible to hear… glad to hear she is better
Caterina (the greek- remember?) xxx

Jill Chestnut July 30, 2009 at 11:05 pm

Nat, such a sad and awful story so well told. It's amazing that sat from my desk here in Sydney that this sort of thing is happening. It's unreal. I'm so glad she's on the road to recovery. Truly special person that worries about you when they are in plight. Love you and miss you every day xxx

John July 31, 2009 at 2:06 pm

i must admit the islands are just a blood bath sometimes especially around full moon
thank god it was not more serious the concrete roads are very unforgiving
and yes i can just see you asking her to put some shoes on and all you got was a smile
well at least she.s on the mend
best wishes John noi jamie

Anonymous August 21, 2009 at 11:09 am

Is there room there for a retired doctor to do some voluntary free work for a few weeks? I do not know the language and do not know how to get a license to do voluntary work? Can you direct me to the right web site?
Thanks
Fran Cerec

Anonymous August 21, 2009 at 10:55 pm

It's a shame about the poor girl's toes and the way she was treated. Wish you all the best.

I wonder if it would have been better not to go to hospital at all for that kind of injury? Could you have purchased antibiotic ointment, rubbing alcohol or hydrogen peroxide, and sterile gauze and tape and dressed the wound at home? That's about all a flesh wound really needs. Clean it well and cover it and keep it clean. Maybe some iodine. Can you buy those first aid supplies where you live?

Sounds like even if the toes were broken they would have been better off set at home than at that "hospital".

Anonymous August 24, 2009 at 10:24 am

Mmmm…I don't know what to say, just incredibly sad. And here I sit with my own toe, having had a simple biopsy done last week, and lamenting my pain and not being able to play tennis. Reality check for me. I'm so sorry. And now keenly grateful. Thank you.

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv Enabled

Previous post: Joe and Egger get a photo from Burma

Next post: High Speed Trains Crash Faster