The Village’s Newest Prostitute

by Jungle Girl on August 20, 2009

I came down yesterday morning to find Shrimp, Crab and Golf all a twitter, two of golf’s teenage pals who had left with their family had returned, shacked up at the Karaoke cum brothel and begun what is sure to be an illustrious career of selling sex.

This was shocking and twitter-inducing to the assembled gossipers because of their age, of only sixteen and their previous friendship with golf. Shrimp was I-told-you-so-ing with grave authority: he had warned Crab months ago against Golf playing with the older girl, her nail varnish, lip gloss and cheeky smile clearly spelled trouble. And here he was proved right. Happy at having saved his niece from an almost inevitable descent into prostitution and drugs, he got on with his chores for the day.

I am confused to say the least. Everybody seems to be frowning and tut-tutting, heaping shame upon the two girls. Yet the girl’s mother was also a bar girl until she took up with Shrimp’s brother in law, at which point everyone decided to forget that fact, as it was better for Shrimp’s neice and nephew that they got a new mother (the old one ran off with a salesman, she was also first cousin of the husband she left).

Now when her daughter joins the profession she learned at her mother’s knee, she is shunned and reviled. It’s not really fair is it? Particularly as Shrimp’s other sister-in-law-cum-pimp runs the karaoke in question. Here the fickle Thai pragmatism-cum-hypocrisy comes into play: it’s okay for sister-in-law to run the Karaoke, it’s okay for Crab to frequent the karaoke and enjoy singing and giving sister-in-law her money, it’s okay for the girl’s mother to have been a prostitute, the only person who is heaped with disapproval is the poor child who has been raised in this environment, shown this example, and made use of the only skills she is aware she might possess.

When she left last year she was a bright, bubbly, trendy looking teenager, with a cheeky smile and a twinkle in her eye. She always greeted me in the street with a friendly hello, and she and Golf were inseparable BFFs for a while, always hanging out on the moped, chewing gum and talking ten to a dozen into their phones.

Today I see the girl strolling down the road. She has the disheveled appearance of someone who has been up all night, and the defensive strut of a girl who is trying to pretend she doesn’t give a dam what the world thinks of her. As she passes her former pals they don’t say a word, afraid perhaps of the dark acts they have been told she has been performing. She feels the air heavy with their judgment and snarls something at them in Thai. They studiously ignore her; her alienation complete.

As I pass her I see her face flicker with recognition, normally she would have called out a boisterous Nataleeee. Now she hesitates searching my face, preparing herself for the rejection that she will surely find writ large upon it. I give her a big smile and a bright hello and relief flashes across her face before she gives me a guarded smile.

Before she had the air of a child bouncing into life with gusto, now something world-weary and hard lurks behind her eyes. From now onwards she will always carry this with her and her life will be shaped accordingly to her new attitude of calculated self-preservation.

I really feel nothing but sadness for this girl, I hope that she can at least find a farang man with some money to make her life comfortable, that she does not succumb to the brutal merry-go-round of yabba-fuelled late nights and abuse at the hands of cheap perverts in the seedy alleys of patpong. Hope she has the nous to keep herself healthy and alive.

This horny thorny issue of prostitution raises its ugly head fairly frequently in Thailand. On a global stage it is perhaps the top bill this country is renowned for. This beautiful nation is utterly synonymous with the seedy underbelly of the world’s oldest profession.

In reality there is of course good reason for this stereotype, like many sterotypes it is based on fact. Here prostitution is an accepted part of life, a necessary evil, part of human nature. It is treated with a fairly honest and pragmatic approach, rather than with the kid gloved delicacy or (denial) of the west.

The sexpat phenomenon I will examine in more detail later, which is an entirely different kettle of fish. But in terms of Thai culture, prostitution is as commonplace as affairs, adultery and divorce are in ours. It is pretty much accepted that men have needs that they naturally desire to fulfill and that is only to be expected.

I think there are possibly two explanations for this acceptance: one an innate pragmatism, two an acceptance of the non-sexuality of the role of mother, my friend P would add a third reason: that Thai men are the most virile on earth.

It’s not surprising that a shattered young mother would find herself too exhausted for sex, many a western mother could certainly sympathise. And in Thailand the man is expected to turn to a prostitute for his fulfillment. Add to that the belief that you cannot have sex with your wife when she is pregnant, and then consider that some women are pregnant, nursing, or childbearing for over a decade. Factor in the respect for motherhood, the role of matriarch, and the absolute respect for their own mothers that is absolutely concrete in this culture of familial strength and you have a heady concoction for sure.

So men use prostitutes. Wives aren’t delighted but it’s okay as it relieves them from the drudgery of their sexual duty and the possibility, god forbid, of more children. But the openness of Thai culture doesn’t stop there, the nuances of the sexual partnerships continue on into realms western men can only dream of.

There are names for all the roles that women play in a man’s life, whether as prostitute, or literally translated “woman sell sex”, or the slightly sweeter “woman have good service”. Gig, a girl that you see regularly outside your marriage, like a mistress, and finally the mier noi, or small wife, whom you literally support as a second wife.

Of these, the mier noi is certainly the most feared by mier luang, “major wives”, as she is given a status second only to herself, including usually a house, children and a chunk of whatever riches the wealthy man is able to provide. Women in these scenarios cannot really kick up a fuss with their husbands, he being the person holding the omnipotent purse strings, so they often declare war on each other and each other’s offspring.

Stories abound of miers one and two attacking and even murdering each other. It’s not uncommon for wives to be sisters, even occasionally a mother and her daughter from a previous marriage. Which goes a long way to explain the explosive popularity of the soap opera as a genre in Thailand.

On the other side of the mier noi controversy, an English friend of ours relates this tale of an English friend who married a thai woman. After her third, difficult, and dangerous pregnancy the wife informed the husband that she’d had enough, of the sex, the pregnancies, the lot. It was, she informed him, time for him to take a mier noi, they could afford it after all, and she would gladly be relieved of this side of her wifely duties. Her appalled, and utterly devoted husband didn’t take this pronouncement too well and it created a fair bit of strife in the marriage. But it is a funny anecdote that accurately describes the commonplace nature of these arrangements.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

Related posts:

  1. Wedding Wednesday

{ 1 trackback }

Jungle Girl from My Jungle Life | Thailand Musings
April 1, 2010 at 11:18 am

{ 14 comments… read them below or add one }

Jill August 20, 2009 at 10:44 pm

Poor girl. You paint such a picture Nat, I'd love to get some of your stuff published over here. Do you send any of it back to the UK at all? Love youxx

Poppy August 21, 2009 at 3:02 am

"That's awesome Nat. Just something about Mia nois. Typically Mia Noi stem from the ancient concubine tradition. The reason men rich men kept concubines was to avoid having to resort to the common prostitutes. Usually Mia Nois are only kept by wealthy men as the man is expected to support both wives. Most Thai men I know can barely support one! The dynamics between mia nois and mia yais vary according to each situation. I know of one friend who's wealthy dad always kept a minimum of 2-3 mia noi. These mia noi were insanely jealous of each other (particulary the newest ones) but very respectfu lto the mia yai. The mia yai tolerated the situation only on the grounds that none of them were EVER to fall pregnant. If they did they had to have an abortion. This agreement was stuck to and now as he is reaching his older life, his mia noi are bcoming much less a part of his life – he has payed most of them off…and he is content being looked after by his first wife."

Anonymous August 21, 2009 at 6:22 am

A 'gik' is really more of an idiom for a casual lover, someone who is not a serious boyfriend or girlfriend but more than just a one-night stand. It is used among those who are not married, and young people, and does not necessarily (or even usually) imply either prostitution or infidelity. It would certainly not equate to 'mistress.'

Anonymous August 21, 2009 at 11:00 am

In your experience. is men protituion as prevalent in Thailand as women's? If so, some of your arguments to explain Thai men having regular sex with prostitutes may not be accurate and viril may include gay sex.
Fran Cerec

john August 21, 2009 at 11:31 am

normally the girls ply there trade away from home our where most of there former friends and familey are and return home at holidays in issan these girls are respected for bringing in money the hows and the whys dont come into it
she is young full of zest no money and wanting more then she as got she could be a university student in Bangkok selling yourself to get on in life but most never do but that's life

Jungle Girl August 21, 2009 at 8:35 pm

Thanks Jill. And Poppy for further clarification about the mier nois.

And anonymous, yes you're right gik can be even more casual than a girlfriend outside your marriage.

Fran Cerec, thanks for your comment – I really don't have enough experience with male prostitution to write an observation, maybe its another post all together? I would be interested to hear your insights.

And John, yes, great point furthering the pragmatism – "the hows and whys don't come into it" if the girls are able to provide a life for their entire family, they aren't judged for what they're doing as they might be in europe – it's accepted that its a means to an end. And when the 'end' is keeping a family from starvation and life on the poverty line then yes the girls can't afford to have comfortable western morals, those are indeed a luxury.

Anonymous August 21, 2009 at 10:29 pm

I am sure those people who turn up their noses at the working girls would be happy to share the profits. In other words, envy is part of it.

Martyn August 29, 2009 at 2:03 pm

Prostitution in Thailand really is a not so merry go round and as one jumps off another climbs on. It's very easy for us westerners to throw stones at glass brothels with no understanding of the real reasons of why and where. I think your post goes a long way to explaining that.

I have always said…if you took away the single parent child benefit payments in the UK then before long there would be a hooker in every bar and on every street corner….I believe that such payments in Thailand would stop all the fun of the fair, but it ain't going to happen.

I must agree with John and say that I am surprised the girl is floating her boat in her home village and not somewhere far away. Poppy's ancient concubine theory is interesting and rings loud and true. Great post. Best wishes to you and I hope the girl pulls through.

Catherine September 4, 2009 at 3:03 am

What a sobering story.

It's an awful business to be in, so I wonder why she'd risk losing the respect of friends and family. I mean, she doesn't have small children to care for, right? From what I've read, it's the common reason for young Thai girls going into prostitution. So, it's not like she has severly limited choices.

Here's hoping she bails under the pressure. Way before she starts taking drugs to dull it out.

Martyn September 4, 2009 at 8:07 am

Catherine 'Here's hoping she bails under the pressure. Way before she starts taking drugs to dull it out.,

I think you hit the nail bang on the head, in fact you may have driven it straight through the floorboards.

Jungle Girl September 4, 2009 at 10:48 am

Thanks for all the comments guys. The update is the karaoke here is closed for now, so most of the girls have left, here's hoping to do something better…. the girl I wrote about is still around and seems to be getting by. This post stirred up quite a lot of resentment amongst the Thai community some of whom felt I was bad mouthing Thailand, I apologise for any misunderstangings, I write what I see, and I try to make the more gritty posts like this one as compassionate as possible. Many thanks everybody.

And Martyn you are spot on, a lot of westerners' initial reaction is prostitute=bad girl. At least in THailand there is more compassion usually towards needs must. Without our cushy welfare state I think it would be a different story for so many people, and you just never know what you might have to do…until you've walked a day in her shoes etc.

That said, Catherine is right this girl is not desperate just trying to make a quick buck. Thailand is so consumer orientated and for some young women the choice to prostitute themselves whether as a hi-so fun girl, or a low-rent bar girl, is a commercial one unfortunately. Here's hoping this girl learns to value her body and self esteem a little more than the latest phone.

Charles Frith September 27, 2009 at 8:55 pm

A brilliant post although there is a viewpoint that suggests any woman in the world stuck in a relationship for reasons of fiscal security is perhaps in a transactional sexual relationship or prostitution if you wish.

It's difficult and complex and most certainly built on context but either way a most respected post. I'm sorry about your bereavement.

Jungle Girl October 2, 2009 at 8:42 am

Thanks for your comment Charles, and you're absolutely right. For those that sniff at bar girls, how far is prostitution from being a trophy wife of a wealthy man really? The lines get very blurred don't they? Which makes it a hell of a lot easier not to judge. And as Martyn pointed out, unsupported by a welfare state how many more of us would be marrying for money or selling our bodies in one way or another at some point?

violetflame October 16, 2009 at 5:27 pm

Jungle Girl, an excellent and very sad descriptive account of your observations! Enjoying the blog!!

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv Enabled

Previous post: High Speed Trains Crash Faster

Next post: Three Years On……